If that was the intention, why even bother with the rest period of doing nothing in the first place - why not just have her instantly heal us?
Having us do nothing shows us nothing about how powerful the JDF is because literally nothing about it is described or elaborated on about the process. It still takes the same rest period as the others.
You're fundamentally misunderstanding how overwhelming advantages are portrayed.
If JDF is truly overpowered, forcing the MC to go through a grueling, traditional recovery process act would actually contradict that no?
The
absence of struggle IS the feat here imo.
It shows a massive gap in tier compared to the other mentors.
If you have a perfectly optimized foundation or top-tier passive recovery, you don't need active physical ****...your body does the heavy lifting passively. The mundane recovery isn't some missing scenes, it's really Eldra flexing how powerful she is lol!
Okay - let's put this another way. Is there anyone who would dislike Eldra's option or find it less attractive if the free time spent interacting with other NPCs was instead replaced with training more in line with the other two mentors? Keeping the JDF content intact of course. If you do, could you explain why?
Yes, absolutely. Because it destroys path variety, which an Interactive Fiction is all about.
The entire point of offering different mentors is to provide distinct narrative experiences. If Eldra’s training is brought "in line" with the other two, she loses her unique identity as the unconventional OP mentor. A lot of players explicitly choose routes with more "free time" because they want to focus on NPC interactions rather than just grinding
Standardizing the mentor routes just because, will just turn the game boring.
Also saying "you could basically ignore the Eldra scenes and nothing would be missed" is just false. You'd miss:
The worldbuilding about different valid paths in cultivation...AGAIN not everything has to be about blood and struggle.
And the characterization of Eldra herself.
Disliking the scene because it didn't feel like "real training" to YOU is valid as personal taste. Claiming it's objectively bad, skippable, or implying that is bad writing because it doesn't match the other two scenes...is just ehhh
Different strokes for different folks. Some people like the chill, OP mentor vibe. Others prefer the stereotypical training montages like you.
Pretending only one is valid because it feels like an real cultivator training or whatever is the real oversimplification here.